Criminal Psychology vs. Forensic Psychology: Which to Choose?

Author: University of North Dakota
June 20, 2024

If you've ever watched an episode of "Criminal Minds," "CSI" or a similar TV show, you're likely aware of the fascinating intersection between psychology and law and its importance in solving crimes.

Fields like criminal psychology and forensic psychology epitomize this junction, offering exciting roles that blend psychological expertise with law enforcement efforts. 

However, although these two fields share some similarities, they differ significantly in practice and focus. So, read on as we compare criminal psychology vs. forensic psychology and learn more about these career paths and how they diverge.

What is Criminal Psychology?

Criminal psychology is a specialized branch of psychology that focuses on understanding the thoughts, intentions, actions and reactions of individuals who engage in criminal behavior. This field encompasses the psychological assessment of people within the criminal justice system, aiming to understand their behavior and predict potential future offenses. 

Criminal psychologists aid the justice system by analyzing criminal minds to identify patterns, motivations or triggers for criminal actions. Their insights help in developing effective methods for profiling and apprehending offenders.

What is Forensic Psychology?

Forensic psychology unites psychology and the legal system, applying psychological principles and scientific methods to solve legal issues. This field involves assessing a wide range of individuals in the legal system, including suspects, victims and witnesses, to understand their psychological state and its impact on their behavior and testimonies.

Forensic psychologists are often called upon to provide expert opinions in various legal contexts, such as family law disputes, civil litigations, insurance claims and criminal proceedings. Their work is crucial in helping legal professionals understand how psychological factors can affect the outcomes of cases.

Similarities Between Criminal Psychology vs. Forensic Psychology

While distinct in their specific applications, criminal psychology and forensic psychology share a common foundation in their use of psychological principles to address issues within the legal system. Both fields require practitioners to possess a robust understanding of human behavior and the skills to assess mental states, which are critical in interpreting the actions and motivations of individuals involved in legal cases.

Another key similarity is their frequent interaction with the legal system. Both criminal and forensic psychologists often provide expert testimony in courtrooms, helping judges and juries understand the psychological elements of a case. Moreover, professionals in both fields employ similar methodologies in their work to develop psychological profiles that can aid law enforcement investigations.

Differences Between Forensic Psychology vs. Criminal Psychology

Despite the similarities between criminal psychology and forensic psychology and their shared goal of applying psychological insights to assist the legal system, there are significant differences that distinguish these two fields.

Education

Forensic psychology education typically starts at the undergraduate level with a bachelor's degree in psychology, criminology or a related field. Following this, individuals interested in advancing their knowledge and opening up more career opportunities may pursue a master's in forensic psychology.

Ultimately, to practice as a forensic psychologist, most professionals must acquire a doctoral degree in psychology specializing in forensic issues. This level of specialized education is necessary to gain deep insights into the complex interplay between psychology and law, preparing them to handle intricate cases involving mental health and legal questions effectively. 

For those looking to specialize further or aim for higher-tier positions, a certificate in forensic psychology offers a targeted approach to enhancing expertise and pivoting professional focus toward forensic applications.

Similarly, education for criminal psychologists starts with an undergraduate degree, which can be in psychology or a related field. For example, a bachelor's degree in forensic science offers a specialized focus on the scientific and investigative aspects relevant to criminal psychology. 

Advancing in the field typically requires graduate-level training. A master's degree in psychology focusing on criminology or criminal psychology deepens understanding of criminal minds and behaviors. This specialized training includes courses in psychological profiling, the psychology of law enforcement and the treatment of criminal populations.

Skills

Forensic psychologists must possess a broad set of skills tailored to navigating the complexities of legal cases and the dynamics of the courtroom, such as:

• Proficiency in understanding legal procedures, terminology and the overall legal system
• The ability to make informed decisions that adhere to both psychological and legal ethical standards
• Skill in presenting psychological findings effectively and credibly in a courtroom setting
• Expertise in conducting thorough psychological evaluations in a legal context
• Ability to provide immediate psychological support in emergencies within the legal system

On the other hand, criminal psychologists require an even deeper understanding of criminal behavior theories and the ability to apply these theories in real-world settings. Their skillset typically includes:

• Ability to create detailed profiles of potential offenders based on behavioral patterns and psychological theories
• Skill in conducting interviews with suspects, victims and witnesses to extract crucial information
• Deep knowledge of theories of criminal behavior and the psychological factors that influence criminality
• Skills in using statistical tools to analyze data and identify trends in criminal behavior
• Capability to manage personal emotions and remain effective when dealing with criminal cases

Roles and Responsibilities

Both forensic and criminal psychologists play significant roles in the justice system. They each contribute in unique but complementary ways to address various issues at the intersection of psychology and law.

Although their exact responsibilities depend on their role and the case they are handling, forensic psychologists typically are in charge of:

• Assessing individuals to determine their mental capacity to stand trial
• Evaluating the likelihood of an individual reoffending and providing these assessments to courts to inform sentencing and parole decisions
• Providing specialized knowledge in court regarding mental health issues that affect legal decisions, such as the insanity defense
• Offering psychological support to victims of crime, helping them cope with the trauma and emotional aftermath

On the other hand, criminal psychologists apply their understanding of psychological principles to criminal behavior through the following responsibilities: 

• Developing profiles of offenders to assist law enforcement in narrowing down suspects and understanding the motivations behind crimes
• Working alongside police in criminal investigations to provide insights that might affect the direction of the investigation
• Advising on techniques for interviewing suspects and witnesses based on psychological principles and behavioral cues
• Researching criminal behavior, recidivism and other related topics to develop more effective crime prevention and management methods

Work Environment

Forensic psychologists are often found in courtrooms, providing expert testimony or assisting in legal proceedings. Their work also takes them to law firms collaborating on case strategies and to government agencies advising on policy and criminal justice issues. 

On the other hand, criminal psychologists typically work closely with law enforcement agencies, in prisons or juvenile facilities implementing rehabilitation programs and as consultants for private firms or independently, applying their expertise to criminal cases and providing training in criminal psychology.

Salary and Job Outlook

The job outlook for psychologists, including specialties such as forensic and criminal psychology, is projected to grow by 6% from 2022 to 2032, faster than the average for all occupations. Over the decade, about 12,800 job openings for psychologists are expected, many of which will arise from the need to replace professionals who retire or transition to other occupations.

Despite their differing work environments and responsibilities, both professions share a similar compensation level, with the average forensic psychologist's salary and criminal psychologist's salary being around $92,813. This indicates the high value placed on their expertise and the critical nature of their work.

Criminal Psychology vs. Forensic Psychology: Which Should You Choose?

Deciding whether to pursue a criminal or forensic psychology career largely depends on your passions and how you envision your contributions to society. If the legal system intrigues you and you appreciate both the complexities of law and psychology, forensic psychology might be your ideal choice. Conversely, criminal psychology could be a better fit if you're drawn to understanding what drives criminal behavior and how to prevent and solve crimes.

To make an informed decision, it's crucial to engage in introspection. Consider what excites you the most about each field, your skills and where you can best apply them. Additionally, speaking with professionals currently working in these fields can provide valuable insights. 

Volunteering or securing internships in both areas can also be extremely beneficial in helping you determine which specialty aligns more closely with your interests and career aspirations.

Conclusion

Whether you're considering a career in criminal psychology or forensic psychology or you're simply curious about their roles, it's essential to understand the distinctions that define and separate these disciplines. So, the key difference lies in their focus areas—criminal psychology primarily deals with understanding criminal behavior to aid law enforcement, while forensic psychology often involves directly interacting with the legal system to address various psychological aspects of legal cases.

At UND, our psychology department has been nurturing minds in this field for over 100 years, helping students achieve success in these and other specialized areas of psychology. We invite you to explore these fields with us, where a rich history of academic excellence promises to enrich your educational journey.

FAQs